Pet insurance leads on trust, but what happens as our pets get older?
Fairer Finance’s latest Trust in Insurance Index highlights encouraging levels of consumer trust in pet insurance, alongside findings that raise important questions about the experiences of customers with ageing pets and those experiencing financial pressure.
The Fairer Finance Trust in Insurance Index (Autumn 2026), published on 8 October, offers encouraging news for the UK pet insurance market.
Pet insurance remains the most trusted of the four insurance sectors surveyed, with an overall trust index score of 56.74%, a slight improvement since Spring 2026.
This is a positive finding for a sector that plays an important role in helping people access veterinary care for their animals.
However, beneath the headline figures are some important differences in reported trust, particularly for customers with older pets and those experiencing financial pressure.
For the Pet and Equine Insurance Association (PEIA), these findings provide useful evidence to inform conversations already taking place across the insurance, veterinary and animal welfare communities.
Trust and the ageing pet
One of the most striking findings relates to the age of insured pets.
Fairer Finance reports that trust index scores decline from 62% among customers with pets aged 1–4 to 50.92% among those with pets over 10 years old.
Claims satisfaction follows a similar pattern. While satisfaction among customers with pets under five has remained relatively stable, the score for those with pets aged five and over has fallen by 4.66 percentage points since Autumn 2025.
Fairer Finance also highlights the challenges associated with changing policy terms as pets age, including percentage co-payments introduced at certain ages and financial limits applying to particular conditions. These arrangements can play a role in managing the cost and sustainability of insurance. However, they can also create unexpected financial responsibilities if customers don’t fully understand how their cover changes over time.
While the research identifies a relationship between pet age and trust, it does not establish precisely what drives it. Changing policy terms may be one factor, alongside increasing veterinary needs, affordability, claims experiences and customer expectations. The findings raise important questions about communication, expectations and how well insurance continues to meet the needs of people as their animals grow older.
When personal experience brings the challenge into focus
These issues are not new to PEIA.
Our CEO, Sharon Brown, recently shared Bella’s story, reflecting on the changing needs of an ageing pet and the challenges of navigating insurance, veterinary care and financial considerations as those needs evolve.
The response prompted considerable discussion among people who have pets, insurance professionals and the wider veterinary and animal welfare communities.
Bella’s story is one example of why it’s important to understand the different needs of animals and their keepers throughout their lives, and how the wider ecosystem can better support them.
These are precisely the kinds of conversations PEIA is encouraging across the sector.
Link to Sharon’s original Bella LinkedIn post here.
Financial pressure and consumer trust
Fairer Finance’s research also identifies a significant gap in trust between customers experiencing financial pressure and those who are not.
Among pet insurance customers who describe their bills as a heavy burden, the trust index score is 50.41%, compared with 62.76% among those who do not consider their bills a burden.
The research also found that pet insurance was the only sector where trust among customers who had made a claim declined between Spring and Autumn 2026. Although this decline was relatively small, it is an interesting finding when considered alongside the differences in claims satisfaction reported for owners of older pets.
These findings don’t suggest that pet insurance is failing as a whole. Indeed, its overall trust score remains comparatively strong.
They do, however, indicate areas where customer experiences and expectations deserve closer attention.
For people with older animals, the combined effect of premiums, policy excesses, co-payments and veterinary costs can become increasingly significant. The research doesn’t tell us whether lower trust reflects different treatment or outcomes, the greater impact of costs on financially stretched households, or a combination of factors. Nor does it capture the full experiences of people who have chosen not to insure, or who can no longer afford insurance. Understanding how these pressures affect decisions, confidence and access to care is important for the long-term sustainability of the pet insurance market.
Conversations are already taking place
At PEIA, the challenges surrounding ageing pets, affordability, changing insurance cover and access to veterinary care are already part of our discussions with members and wider stakeholders.
Our September Members’ Forum, The Human Side of Pet Insurance, brought together insurance professionals, veterinary teams and animal welfare representatives to explore the experiences of people and animals at the heart of these issues.
The willingness to engage openly with difficult subjects has been encouraging.
There is growing recognition that these challenges cannot always be considered in isolation. Insurance products, veterinary care, communication, consumer understanding and animal welfare are closely connected.
PEIA’s role is to bring these different perspectives together, facilitate constructive conversations and help develop a shared understanding of where improvements may be possible.
Building the evidence through The Pet Pledge
These themes are also central to The Pet Pledge, PEIA’s programme focused on improving access to care through a more sustainable, trusted and joined-up pet and equine insurance ecosystem.
Our Companion Animal Welfare Journey research is examining experiences across an animal’s life, from the earliest decisions about ownership through to later-life care and end-of-life considerations.
By listening to people who have pets, veterinary professionals, insurers and the wider welfare community, the research aims to identify where expectations and experiences differ, where challenges arise and where opportunities for improvement may exist.
Independent evidence, including research such as the Fairer Finance Trust in Insurance Index, provides valuable context for this work.
Surveys of consumer perceptions can highlight important patterns, but they do not necessarily explain what causes them. Their value lies in helping us identify where further investigation is needed, rather than drawing definitive conclusions from the findings alone.
By exploring these findings alongside wider evidence and different stakeholder experiences, we can build a more complete understanding of the challenges and opportunities across the companion animal care journey.
Maintaining trust throughout an animal’s life
Being the most trusted of the four insurance sectors surveyed is positive news for pet insurance.
But trust is not static. It can be influenced by changing circumstances, expectations and experiences, particularly as pets grow older or require more complex veterinary care.
The challenge for the sector is not simply to build trust at the point of purchase, but to consider how that trust can be maintained throughout an animal’s life.
For PEIA, this is an important part of the wider conversation about animal welfare, access to care and the long-term sustainability of pet insurance.
The encouraging news is that these conversations are already happening. The opportunity now is to build the evidence, strengthen collaboration and identify where meaningful progress can be made.
We thank Fairer Finance for this valuable research and for continuing to highlight issues that matter to consumers and the wider insurance sector.
Read the original research:
https://www.fairerfinance.com/insights/blog/the-fairer-finance-trust-in-insurance-index-autumn-2026
Source: Fairer Finance Trust in Insurance Index, Autumn 2026. Trust figures are index scores based on customer survey responses, rather than percentages of customers expressing trust. The Index combines six survey waves, with greater weighting given to more recent responses.
Bringing the pet and equine community together to support sustainable insurance, access to care and animal welfare.
27 Old Gloucester Street, London, WC1N 3AX
VAT number 509422109
Company number 16176404